| Year | ACC# | Set Name | Card # | Price | Photo | Variation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1887 | N172 | Old Judge | 76-1a | Hands on hips-Brooklyns | ||
| 1887 | N172 | Old Judge | 76-2a | Stooping-hands on knees-Brooklyns | ||
| 1887 | N172 | Old Judge | 76-3a | Catch-hands above waist-Brooklyns | ||
| 1887 | N172 | Old Judge | 76-4a | Catch-hands shoulder high-Brooklyns | ||
| 1887 | N172 | Old Judge | 76-5a | Throw-R/hand shoulder high-Brooklyns | ||
| 1887 | N172 | Old Judge | 76-6a | Tagging Hughes-Brooklyns | ||
| 1887 | N172 | Old Judge | 76-7a | Bat at ready nearly vertical-Brooklyns | ||
| 1889 | Police Gazette Cabinets | |||||
| 1976 | TCMA Quad City Angels | |||||
| 1982 | Topps | 74 | Blackless | |||
| 1985 | Gardner's Brewers | 3 |
